Post #5: Distinctive Due Diligence: Manufacturing Company Excellence

In this second article of our series on the due diligence process, we delve deeper into the methodologies for identifying highly attractive businesses for acquisition. A cornerstone of our exploration is the utilization of Porter's Five Forces framework, an essential tool for evaluating a business's competitive environment and its attractiveness in the market.

If you do nothing else subscribe to the newsletter here

The Critical Role of Due Diligence:

Commercial due diligence stands at the forefront of identifying not just viable, but attractive companies for acquisition. The process pressure-tests the traits that set apart potential investment opportunities from their peers. By examining the company through several lenses (customer, supplier, employee for example), investors can discern the long-term value and potential growth of a business.

Porter's Five Forces: A Fundamental Evaluation Tool:

Porter's Five Forces model provides a comprehensive method for assessing the competitive dynamics affecting a business. These forces are all pretty intuitive; they allow investors to gauge a business's position and resilience within its industry. Often, the score of the business against these metrics translates directly into the margin profile of the business and ultimately the cashflow generation of the business.

• the bargaining power of suppliers

• bargaining power of customers

• threat of new entrants

• threat of substitute products or services

• intensity of competitive rivalry

The importance of free cash flow

One distinction between me and many other investment writers is my intense focus on free cash flow rather than net income or EBITDA. EBITDA and net income are directional drivers of free cash flow but ultimately, the driver of investment is the cash on cash return, not the accounting treatment of cash flows.

Characteristics of High-Value Manufacturing Businesses:

High-value manufacturing businesses exhibit several distinct characteristics that contribute to their attractiveness:

• Diversified Supplier and Customer Base: Businesses that are not overly reliant on a small number of suppliers or customers are better positioned to negotiate favorable terms and withstand market fluctuations.

• Unique and Hard-to-Replicate Products: Manufacturing businesses producing highly engineered products that are difficult for competitors to replicate enjoy higher barriers to entry and greater pricing power.

• Strong Pricing Power Relative to Competition: Companies like Transdigm in the aerospace industry illustrate the advantage of strong pricing power, leading to superior profit margins.

• Superior Margins and High Return on Assets: Examining a company's margins and return on assets, especially when considering free cash flow relative to assets, reveals its efficiency and financial health.

• Attractive Working Capital Dynamics: Companies that can negotiate favorable payment terms, such as receiving payments before delivering goods, can use this cash flow advantage to further solidify their market position.

Case Studies: Examining Success Stories:

Two examples to bring some of the above concepts to life

• Example Company A: Transdigm, an aerospace parts manufacturer has made a business of acquiring manufacturers of (often sole source) mission critical components for aircraft, and aggressively bargaining with fleets, service operators on their pricing

• Example Company B: Walmart is in a negative working capital due to turning its stock to customers faster on average than it needs to pay vendors. Vendors typically finance their stock to Walmart on net 30 or net 45 terms - as a result, Walmart’s capital efficiency is much higher than that of local stores which typically purchase products from vendors to sell over time to customers.

The combination of a strategic approach to due diligence and the insights provided by Porter's Five Forces offers a powerful toolkit for investors aiming to pinpoint attractive acquisition targets.

Stay tuned for the next article in our series, where we'll explore the financial metrics and operational indicators that distinguish exceptional service businesses from the rest.

Tweets too good to miss

Thinking about online business: https://tinyurl.com/SMBonlinebusiness

Finding a peer group: https://tinyurl.com/SMBpeergroups

The perfect SMB doesn’t ex-: https://tinyurl.com/perfectcompany

Parting thoughts

I hope you have enjoyed this read. If you are not already, subscribe here.

• How can I make this newsletter better?

• What would you like to read about?

If you have any questions about this article or about value creation for your business, shoot me an email at [email protected]. I will be happy to respond to all the notes that I can. Look out for a follow up post soon.

If you are looking for a thought partner with whom to think through the growth of your business, I’m also happy to chat. Again, I’m an email away.